Joanna Cherry, a former SNP MP, has voiced serious concerns about the party's future after its significant losses in the recent general election, where they went from 48 seats to just nine. She criticized First Minister John Swinney for not adequately addressing the reasons behind this electoral disaster and highlighted a troubling 'culture of hate' within the party that stifles debate and dissent. Cherry, who will step back from frontline politics to reflect on the party's direction, warned that without urgent introspection and reform, the SNP risks remaining in opposition at Holyrood. She emphasized the need for the party leadership to recognize the gravity of the situation and to foster an environment where open discussion is encouraged. Additionally, she noted that the SNP's support for Scottish independence is at risk if internal issues are not resolved, citing a drastic drop in votes compared to previous elections. Cherry remains committed to the party but intends to do so from a distance until necessary changes are made.