Keir Starmer has defended the government's decision to means-test winter fuel payments for pensioners, citing a £22 billion shortfall in public finances that necessitates 'tough choices.' Approximately 10 million pensioners who do not receive income-related benefits like Pension Credit will lose payments of up to £300, sparking significant backlash from charities such as Age UK, which has gathered over 466,700 signatures on a petition to reverse the decision. Commons Leader Lucy Powell emphasized that the decision was essential to prevent economic instability, asserting that failing to act could lead to a run on the pound. Critics, including opposition leaders, have called for a parliamentary vote on the matter, labeling it the government's first major error. Despite the pressure, the government remains firm on its stance, citing long-term commitments to the triple lock on pensions as a measure to protect pensioners. The controversy highlights a growing divide over economic policy and its impact on vulnerable populations.